Join our community of smart investors
Opinion

Scottish yes "would hit sterling"

Scottish yes "would hit sterling"
September 11, 2014
Scottish yes "would hit sterling"

This isn’t simply because the FX market hates uncertainty. One reason is that the negotiations about the terms of Scotland’s departure from the UK might depress capital spending; most economists agree that uncertainty causes firms to delay irreversible investments such as location decisions. This - or the fear of it - would cause the Bank of England to postpone a rate rise and lower future interest rates naturally mean a weaker exchange rate.

Also, if Scotland uses sterling without the rest of the UK agreeing to a currency union, it would - as economists at the NIESR point out - need to run an external surplus. This would require a weaker pound in order to boost export revenues.

Thirdly, says Brian Hilliard at Societe Generale, a Scottish yes would increase the chances of the rest of the UK leaving the EU. This is because it would increase the chances of there being a Conservative government which has promised a referendum on exit, while removing the pro-EU Scots from the UK electorate.

Equally, though, says Trevor Greetham at Fidelity, a no vote on September 18 would cause a "strong bounce" in sterling by reducing these risks.

Such a bounce might be only temporary, however. Official figures this week showed that the UK has a big and growing trade deficit, which could eventually hit the pound. And the ECB’s decision to print money to buy asset-backed securities could weaken the euro. And sterling usually falls against the US dollar when the euro does so.