Join our community of smart investors

Crazy times for Coppock

Recent political events are yet to show up in Coppock's signals, which paint an overwhelmingly bullish picture
November 17, 2016

Two weeks ago predictions of a Trump victory were thin on the ground - and as a result Coppock's October readings are largely in line with a continuation of the status quo that the widely predicted election of Hillary Clinton would bring. Clinton did not win, of course, and the unusual market gyrations that we have since seen suggest Coppock's almost uniform bullishness across most asset classes and equity markets is likely to be severely tested.

As it happens, new buy signals on flip-flopping European markets, look well timed, given that rather than collapsing - as many had predicted - western markets have mostly rallied since the Trump victory, particularly in the US where indices touched record highs; Coppock signals flipped to buy earlier this year.

Fixed income, on the other hand, has suffered, with yields on US Treasuries spiking in the aftermath of the election. As a result many are suggesting the unusually tight correlations between bonds and equities will now revert to a more normal relationship, and that bonds' long bull run might finally be over.

Yet Coppock has recently called the end of the bond bull market once before, in mid-2015, only to reverse those signals a year later when it became clear that bonds were still in demand as a safe haven for investors as global growth fears mounted in the first half of 2016. The same is true of gold, another safe haven asset, which flipped to buy in January and has risen steadily ever since. That run was also unexpectedly brought to an end by the post-election risk-on rally.

But unnerving though the very recent moves in safe-haven assets have been, it is again probably too early to say whether the bubble has now burst for good - there is simply no clarity on whether Trump's policies will be inflationary and whether the US interest rate cycle will turn upwards. Such a move would similarly hit emerging markets - which have also been weak since Trump's victory, but largely remain in Coppock buy territory.

For now, then, Coppock devotees would do well to stick to the mechanical nature of the system than attempt to interpret the increasingly difficult-to-decipher relationship between markets and protectionist geopolitics.

 

October's Coppock signals

North AmericaJulAugSepOctLatest signalLatest signal (date)
S&P 500 Composite1.014.295.326.81BUYMay-16
Dow Jones Industrial Average0.513.8357.02BUYMay-16
Nasdaq 1005.337.968.489.99CANCEL SELLJul-16
Nasdaq Composite-0.052.593.635.17BUYJul-16
S&P/TSX-13.38-8.49-4.080.89BUYApr-16
Asia Pacific, Africa
Bangkok SET-12.47-5.93-1.663.64BUYApr-16
FTSE Bursa Malaysia KLCI-11.82-9.06-7.91-5.37BUYFeb-16
FTSE China B35-27.29-29.74-29.97-28.32BUY*Oct-16
Hang Seng-33.45-28.35-23.52-16.55BUYJul-16
Korea SE Composite-4.91-3.92-3.02-1.57BUYJul-16
Indonesia Jakarta Composite-9.3340.2347.71815.932BUYMar-16
Singapore Straits Times-31.09-27.94-25.05-20.66BUYJun-16
Taiwan SE Weighted-15.54-10.88-5.790.98BUYMay-16
Japan Topix-23.4-26.01-29.62-29.44BUY*Oct-16
Australia ASX 200-13.7-9.7-7.6-4.6BUYJul-16
New ZealandNZ 5025.0730.8332.7732.66SELL*Oct-16
South Africa JSE TOP 400.320.56-1.12-1.98CANCEL BUYSep-16
India Sensex-11.68-7.14-4.30.07BUYMay-16
South America
Mexico IPC (Bolsa)5.98.319.4111.83CANCEL SELLMar-16
Brazil Bovespa-6.593.1812.3227.7BUYMar-16
MSCI EM Latin America US%-31.227-18.973-8.5947.612BUYJan-16
Europe/UK
Netherlands AEX-11.3-9.66-10.42-8.96BUY*Oct-16
Greece Athex Composite-54.72-51.36-50.16-42.63BUYJul-16
ATX Austrian Traded-14.64-13.42-12.76-9.66SELLJan-16
Belgium Bel 20-6.88-5.96-6.98-6.75BUY*Oct-16
Germany Dax 30-15.39-12.99-13.31-11.36BUY*Oct-16
Euro Stoxx 50-25.104-24.69-26.434-25.585BUY*Oct-16
France Cac 40-15.18-15.4-17.6-17.15BUY*Oct-16
FTSE 100-11.75-6.51-2.582.68BUYMay-16
FTSE 250-2.43-1.56-0.9-0.35SELLJan-16
FTSE All Share-9.96-5.52-2.162.24BUYJun-16
FTSE MIB-36.22-40.47-45.72-47.48SELLDec-15
Ibex 35-39.06-38.28-38.73-36.04BUY*Oct-16
Ireland SE General (ISEQ)19.2215.29.573.56SELLJan-16
OMX Stockholm 30-26.11-24.15-23.13-20.58SELLJun-15
Oslo Exchange All share-3.45-1.37-0.243.03BUYJul-16
Portugal PSI 20-24.98-25.73-28.63-28.82CANCEL BUYFeb-16
Russia MICEX Index30.832.0932.3531.69SELL*Oct-16
Swiss Market Index-19.18-18.41-19.68-20.8CANCEL BUYSep-16
Fixed Income
Barclays US Aggregate Bond1.9452.7643.3353.462BUYApr-16
US 10y Treasury6.157.3838.2628.448CANCEL SELLApr-16
UK 10y Treasury10.34713.93216.71217.088CANCEL SELLMay-16
Japan 10y Treasury10.27810.54510.66410.505SELL*Oct-16
Germany 10y Treasury8.64610.40211.78312.182CANCEL SELLMay-16
FT All Govt7.54411.40713.85914.449CANCEL SELLMay-16
IBOXX Liquid £ Corp Long-dated-0.5666.5711.42813.891BUYMay-16
FTSE British Govt index linked all mats10.5318.1424.3229.52CANCEL SELLJun-16
Commodities (S&P Goldman Sachs Total Return indices)
Agriculture-12.68-14.9-13.66-10.48BUYSep-16
Industrial Metals-32.37-27.35-19.58-10.75BUYFeb-16
Livestock-31.65-31.81-35.7-37.04CANCEL BUYJul-16
Precious Metals10.615.8621.4425.25BUYJan-16
Gold Bullion11.4516.4221.9225.6BUYJan-16
Crude Oil-86.41-83.51-77.06-70.79BUYFeb-16
*New signals