Zweig screen update
- Created:
- 12 May 2008
- Written by:
- David Stevenson
April was another very solid month for this portfolio, up over 4 per cent in the last month. Total gains across the portfolio, including losses on sold stocks, now totals 32.47 per cent. On current holdings only, the average gain is 55 per cent overall and it's worth noting that amongst our very latest buys - stocks recommended in the last few months - all bar Stanley Gibbons are up, with an average gain of just under 4 per cent.
This month I've found one new addition to the portfolio - and I'm recommending taking some profits on some of our star resource outfits:
• Take profits on Tullow Oil (up 240 per cent) and BHP Billiton (up 142 per cent). I think that both these companies are currently over-valued. Both are great companies, but Tullow now trades at 51 times its current earnings, while BHPBilliton, embroiled in a protracted bid struggle with rival Rio Tinto, is on 17 times earnings. The price rises seen above are way above those of companies like Dragon Oil or JKX Oil & Gas, which have far more scope to add to reserves and production.
• Buy Stagecoach
. This Scottish transport conglomerate is rightly regarded by the city as 'best in class'. To understand why, you only have to look at its latest results from the end of April which showed that trading since late February has 'exceeded expectations' and its outlook is 'positive'. By far the most valuable bit of the business is the commuter rail business, ferrying commuters from Surrey and Hampshire into London Waterloo, plus its stake in Virgin Rail. What seems to be especially gratifying about these recent results is that profits look like they're set to exceed market expectations despite the huge increase in oil costs. If the price of oil starts to fall later this year, as I expect it to, Stagecoach could do even better, maybe pushing earnings above 25p a share, implying EPS growth of beyond 20 per cent. Buy at 250p a share.
Latest Zweig portfolio stats
| Name |
EPIC |
Return (%) |
Notes |
Close |
| Axon Group PLC
|
AXO |
60.7 |
|
5.255 |
| Babcock International Group PLC
|
BAB |
7.6 |
|
5.98 |
| BHP Billiton PLC
|
BLT |
142.2 |
|
19.4 |
| Detica Group PLC
|
DCA |
29.8 |
|
3.115 |
| Dragon Oil PLC
|
DGO |
34.3 |
|
5.6 |
| Goals Soccer Centres PLC
|
GOAL |
17.2 |
|
2.78 |
| Tullow Oil PLC
|
TLW |
240.9 |
|
9.205 |
| Vedanta Resources PLC
|
VED |
332.3 |
|
24.47 |
| JKX Oil & Gas PLC
|
JKX |
31.9 |
|
5.04 |
| John Wood Group PLC
|
WG. |
16.2 |
|
4.4725 |
| Ashmore Group PLC
|
ASHM |
12 |
|
2.9525 |
| RECENT BUYS |
| Stanley Gibbons Group (The) Ltd
|
SGI |
-1.8 |
|
1.915 |
| NCC Group PLC
|
NCC |
2.9 |
|
3.91 |
| Homeserve PLC
|
HSV |
6.5 |
|
20.57 |
| Connaught PLC
|
CNT |
5.2 |
|
4.165 |
| Aggreko PLC
|
AGK |
5.9 |
|
6.345 |
| Velti PLC
|
VEL |
4.9 |
|
1.7 |
|
| Care UK PLC
|
CUK |
-27 |
SOLD |
4.505 |
| Croda International PLC
|
CRDA |
-20 |
SOLD |
7.15 |
| CSR PLC
|
CSR |
-34 |
SOLD |
3.18 |
| Loanmakers Holdings PLC |
LMH |
-50 |
SOLD |
0.0475 |
| ROK PLC
|
ROK |
-48.3 |
SOLD |
1.2975 |
| PlusNet PLC
|
PNT |
-22.6 |
TAKEN OVER |
2.075 |
| Average |
|
32.47 |
|
|
Meanwhile, the market has continued to stabilize in the last four weeks, pushing past 6000 points ahd heading for 6300. However, this hasn't changed my view, which remains that the market will correct.
The recent spike in the FTSE 100 is all down to commodities stocks, as the table below shows. Nine out of the top ten gainers in the FTSE are miners or oil producers - only British Energy, a bid target, is not. If you look at all the resource stocks in the FTSE, they've clocked up a 24 per cent gain. That's equivalent to between 450 and 500 points on the FTSE 100.
| Name |
Close |
Price rise (%) |
|
|
Over 1 month |
Over 3 months |
| Eurasian Natural Resources |
13.1 |
48.02 |
105.17 |
| BHP Billiton |
18.49 |
35.86 |
33.41 |
| Antofagasta |
8.085 |
29.98 |
27.83 |
| Rio Tinto |
61.93 |
29.02 |
37.04 |
| Anglo American |
34.08 |
27.5 |
24.88 |
| Vedanta Resources |
23.63 |
24.24 |
38.51 |
| BG Group |
12.77 |
23.14 |
27.32 |
| British Energy |
7.53 |
21.26 |
53.13 |
| Tullow Oil |
7.45 |
20.65 |
30.7 |
| Royal Dutch Shell |
19.22 |
20.28 |
6.84 |
|
|
27.995 |
|
Any sign that the commodities boom is waning will puncture this buoyancy and the market will sink like a lead weight.
ZWEIG SCREEN BASICS...
This is a classic, higher risk, growth screen with a twist - based on the writings of American investing guru Martin Zweig, it insists on buying fast growing companies where earnings growth is accelerating but the share price is still relatively cheap.
Look for:
• EPS growth in current year is at least 20 per cent
• EPS growth over last 3 years is at least 15 per cent
• EPS growth over last five years is at least 10 per cent. With all these three figures put them side by side and look for evidence of earnings acceleration i.e current EPS growth rate more than 3 year and preferably more than 5 year rate
• Relative strength (of the share price ) over last one year , and the last 3 months, should be at least positive
• PER should be above 5 and below 40
• PEG below 1
• Sales per share trend above 10 per cent i.e sales growing
• Market cap set at a minimum of £35m