Join our community of smart investors

Nearly match over for Rugby Estates

The property company is making progress with its wind-up strategy, but more slowly and less profitably than hoped
October 31, 2012

Egged on by activist investor Laxey Partners, shareholders in Rugby Estates (RES) voted in December 2008 to liquidate the company. The rationale was that the property fund's shares were trading at a big discount to their underlying net asset value (NAV), so investors would be best served by an orderly sale process.

IC TIP: Hold at 393p

That process is now coming to an end, with £51.8m already distributed to shareholders, including £6.4m in July. Chief executive Andrew Wilson - now working part-time - says he hopes to have sold Rugby's remaining six properties by the first or second quarter of 2013. But don't be fooled by the apparent discount to NAV - after roughly £1.9m of liquidation costs, he hopes to realise between 370p and 470p per share, with the risks "weighted towards the downside".

This is a wide range that has been reduced since the May annual results. That's because Mr Wilson is now selling "the rump of the portfolio" into a weak market. The largest asset is a residential land site in Bridgwater, Somerset. Although housebuilders have hit a purple patch, demand for land outside of London remains mixed. Moreover, some of the commercial properties are vacant and others have short leases. "It's hard to obtain debt, and those who have equity know the strength of their position. It's a buyers' market," says Mr Wilson. A number of potential deals have fallen through.

RUGBY ESTATES (RES)

ORD PRICE:393pMARKET VALUE:£4.32m
TOUCH:380-405p12-MONTH HIGH:462pLOW: 393p
DIVIDEND YIELD:nilTRADING PROPERTIES:£5.67m
DISCOUNT TO NAV:35%
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES:nilNET CASH:£2.55m

Half-year to 31 JulNet asset value (p)Pre-tax profit (£m)Earnings per share (p)Dividend per share (p)
2011612-0.64-61nil
2012609-2.33-215nil
% change----