Join our community of smart investors

M&C Saatchi board in disarray

Exec directors add to holdings while Lord Saatchi and three non-execs quit the board
December 11, 2019

The M&C Saatchi (SAA) board is in tatters after founder Maurice Saatchi quit alongside the company’s three non-executive directors.

IC TIP: Sell at 101p

Last week, an accounting review found M&C Saatchi had got its numbers wrong over a period of years and the company issued a profit warning. The accounting issues came up in a review of the books by PwC, and will lead to adjustments of £11.6m, spread between the 2018 and 2019 results. This had been flagged in the half-year results released in September but the total figure was around £6m higher than previously thought. 

Following this latest bout of bad news executive directors David Kershaw, Bill Muirhead and Jeremy Sinclair each bought 415,323 shares in the company at 79.7p, taking their overall holding to 14.8 per cent collectively. The three have now each overtaken Maurice Saatchi's 4.5 per cent stake. The company’s share price plunged after the accounting review announcement, falling by 46 per cent to 79p. The resignations of Lord Saatchi and the non-executive directors did not have the same effect, causing a 4 per cent drop after the share price had returned to over 100p. 

Chairman Jeremy Sinclair did not address Lord Saatchi’s exit in his statement, but said the board would be reconstructed and be handed a new task. “This new board will have a mandate to conduct a full review of all aspects of our governance,” he said. 

Buys       
CompanyDirectorDateNo of sharesPrice (p)Value (£)Holding (shares)Holding (%)
Anglo PacificGraeme Dacomb4 Dec 195,0001809,00025,0000.010
FutureZillah Byng-Thorne (ceo)3 Dec 1911,96212.54150,003462,0150.47
FuturePenny Ladkin-Brand (cfo)3 Dec 197,97412.5499,994519,6660.53
Intermediate CapitalMichael Nelligan3 Dec 196,5761548.18101,808150,0000.051
IomartRichard Masters2 Dec 193,000354.510,6353,0000.003
Iomart♥Richard Masters2 Dec 193,000354.510,6356,0000.006
M&C SaatchiJeremy Sinclair (ch)4 Dec 19415,32379.7331,0124,579,6974.920
M&C SaatchiDavid Kershaw (ceo)4 Dec 19415,32379.7331,0124,579,6974.920
M&C SaatchiBill Muirhead 4 Dec 19415,32379.7331,0124,579,6974.920
ReachJim Mullen (ceo)3 Dec 19100,000100100,000 100,000 0.033
U&IRichard Upton3 Dec 1912,75114918,999nana
U&IRichard Upton28 Nov 1976,027149113,280nana
Ten LifestyleAlan Donald (cfo)3 Dec 1925,00011929,75075,0000.090
Sells       
CompanyDirectorDateNo of sharesPrice (p)Value (£)Holding (shares)Holding (%)
AvastUlf Claesson4 Dec 19500,000434.40872,172,0441,710,0980.17
Amigo Loans†Stephan Wilcke (ch)28-29 Nov 191,800,00063.58951,144,61110,155,6132.137
Amigo Loans††Naynesh Patel28-29 Nov 19703,51465.3754459,9251,460,0000.307
BoohooMahmud Kamani (ch)9 Dec 1935,000,00028599,750,000152,679,88013.100
BoohooCarol Kane9 Dec 1915,000,00028542,750,00031,330,4212.700
KainosRichard McCann (cfo and coo)29 Nov 191,500,0005808,700,0004,711,5823.880
LondonmetricPatrick Vaughan28 Nov 19400,000236.2944,80011,200,0001.331
        
*Placing/tender/open offer/right issue ♥Spouse/connected party       
†Shares sold by Stephan Wilcke ahead of a personal tax liability due in 2020     
††Shares sold by Naynesh Patel ahead of a personal tax liability due in 2020