Join our community of smart investors

Cash out of G4S

The group is trying to reinvent itself as a technology-focused security company, but its track record leaves us underwhelmed
April 2, 2020

The appointment of Ashley Almanza as chief executive of G4S (GFS) in 2013 was meant to herald a new era, especially after the bungled London Olympics security contract. He didn't enjoy the most auspicious start, with the emergence of the electronic tagging scandal for which it had to pay the government £109m plus VAT. Having cleared that hurdle, the group has continued to underwhelm. Excluding the recent ‘corona-crunch’, G4S’s share price at the beginning of January had made little progress since Mr Almanza’s tenure began. It may be a specialist at handling cash, but it has done little for shareholders’ money. 

IC TIP: Sell at 87.4p
Tip style
Sell
Risk rating
High
Timescale
Medium Term
Bull points

Cash solutions sale

Shift towards higher-margin activities

Bear points

High net debt

Pension deficit

Earnings adjustments

Lack of share price momentum

‘Secure solutions’ accounted for over four-fifths of revenue in 2019, split across security solutions and the much smaller ‘care and justice’ operation. The division provides services such as risk consulting, and mobile and remote security. It is looking to shift more towards “technology-enabled” security solutions, which comprised 47 per cent of the division’s sales last year. The group is also keen to increase the 11 per cent of revenue it gets from ‘secure consulting and technology’, given expected adjusted operating margins of 8-15 per cent versus 5-6 per cent for the secure solutions division. 

The pivot follows an agreement to sell almost two-thirds of its conventional cash collections business to US security specialist Brink’s. This came more than a year after it started “reviewing options” to separate the entire cash solutions division. Cash solutions encompasses ‘conventional cash’ and the faster-growing ‘cash technology’, which involves providing software. The disposal is for an enterprise value of £727m, £93m lower than the £820m sum-of-the-parts valuation put on the business by broker RBC. 

It’s not a clean break, with RBC calling the pensions millstone a “poison pill” to divesting the domestic cash business. The UK represented the bulk of the £411m net pension deficit in 2019, up from £364m a year earlier. Net debt has also remained stubbornly high. From £1.55bn in 2013, net debt reached £2.09bn last year (including £310m in lease liabilities), equivalent to 2.88 times cash profits (Ebitda). The £670m net cash proceeds from the sale to Brink’s should reduce leverage to within the target range of 2 to 2.5 times Ebitda. 

G4S’s tendency to adjust earnings for hefty exceptional charges muddies the profitability picture (see chart below). Last year saw a £291m goodwill impairment, largely relating to the UK cash solutions business as cash usage declines. This helped almost halve statutory operating profit to £145m, while the adjusted figure came in 4 per cent higher at £501m.

 

 

G4S (GFS)     
ORD PRICE:87.4pMARKET VALUE:£1.4bn  
TOUCH:87.4-88.4p12-MONTH HIGH:242pLOW:75.5p
FORWARD DIVIDEND YIELD:11.1%FORWARD PE RATIO:6  
NET ASSET VALUE:17.5p*NET DEBT:£2.2bn**  
Year to 31 DecTurnover (£bn)Pre-tax profit (£m)***Earnings per share (p)***Dividend per share (p) 
20177.4337317.99.70 
20187.2836116.79.70 
20197.6737717.09.70 
2020**7.0531214.39.70 
2021**7.3136016.59.70 
% change+4+15+15- 
Normal market size:10,000    
Beta:1.30    
*Includes intangible assets of £1.5bn, or 96.1p a share
**Includes lease liabilities of £310m
***RBC Capital Markets forecasts, adjusted PTP and EPS figures