Join our community of smart investors

AO World still too rich

The appliances retailer is pushing into Europe, but UK growth is slowing
October 18, 2018

Online electrical and white goods business AO World (AO.) has failed to emerge from a lossmaking position during the past four years as a public company and, despite its efforts to build the brand and expand across Europe, there is still a lot to do if the business is to realise its potential. With the medium domestic appliance (MDA) market struggling due to low UK consumer confidence, and online penetration growth behind expectations, we think the company may struggle to meet forecasts for its inaugural cash profits this year. However, the valuation being put on the business suggests the market is looking for broker upgrades.

IC TIP: Sell at 136p
Tip style
Sell
Risk rating
High
Timescale
Medium Term
Bull points

European expansion

Net cash

Bear points

Lossmaking

Challenging appliances market

Slower UK growth

High valuation

A recent strategy day for City analysts underwhelmed when it came to shedding light on how the group would progress from a sales-growth story to a profit-growth story. True, the group has appointed several senior managers with the specific expertise to help build business-to-business relationships, capitalise on rental and recycling trends and expand the company’s foray into insurance ‘aftercare’ policies as it phases out warranty work. There is also potentially scope to license the platform as well as for third-party logistics. And the company is using its impressive infrastructure to expand away from its traditional MDA market. However, analysts at Shore Capital said they saw “no clear roadmap” on how or when the company would turn these opportunities into “meaningful” revenue or earnings growth.

And while much of the focus remains on rolling out the brand across continental Europe, sales in the region only accounted for 16 per cent of the total last year, while trading in the core UK market looks tough. Growth in online penetration in the UK electrical market has been disappointing and is currently estimated to stand at 38 per cent, compared with 30 per cent when AO floated in 2014.

A drop in consumer confidence since the EU referendum has also led to falling MDA volumes, which has exacerbated tough competition in the sector. Indeed, when the company reported on its first quarter to the end of June, it blamed “a slower performance in June” across “core markets” for UK growth of 8 per cent for the quarter as a whole compared with previously reported double-digit growth in the first two months in the period. This still compared favourably with the 2.5 per cent growth in the previous year. Poor trading conditions and competition has also put pressure on AO to keep spending on marketing.

While AO’s European business remains diminutive in size, its growth is more impressive. First-quarter sales growth here came in at 46.2 per cent, compared with 57.6 per cent during the same period last year. As per the full-year results released in June, management has pulled back on promotional activity in Europe to try to improve overall returns.

A quick glance at the balance sheet tells us the group is well-funded with a useful net cash position. However the company has been getting through cash fast and the balance sheet benefited from a £50m share placing in April 2017 that increased shares in issue by 9 per cent. Last financial year saw £15.4m of cash sucked up by operating activities. Adding in capital expenditure, the group experienced free cash outflow of £20.6m for the year.

AO WORLD (AO.)    
ORD PRICE:136pMARKET VALUE:£623m
TOUCH:135.8-137p12M HIGH / LOW:180p98p
FWD DIVIDEND YIELD:NILFWD PE RATIO:65
NET ASSET VALUE:18pNET CASH:£38.2m
Year to 31 MarTurnover (£m)Pre-tax profit (£m)*Earnings per share (p)*Dividend per share (p)
2016599-6.7-1.4nil
2017701-2.8-0.8nil
2018797-10.9-2.9nil
2019*857-4.9-0.9nil
2020*94811.72.1nil
% change+11---
NMS:15,000   
BETA:0.41   
*Shore Cap forecasts, adjusted PTP and EPS figures