Join our community of smart investors

Castings a serious doubt

The iron castings business is years away from profitability
February 7, 2019

Castings (CGS) is in a mess. In 2017, the iron castings business warned that its troubled machining division, CNC Speedwell, would take two years to return to its previous turnover and profitability levels. A year later, management told us that it would need “at least two years” to drive out inefficiencies and turn CNC around, “such is the magnitude of the things we need to do”. Castings’ woes go beyond its machining business. Its foundry business is inefficient too and profits are falling. And while there is comfort in the cash pile, the quality of the balance sheet has been deteriorating and Castings has a herculean task ahead with years of problems to address. We don't think it's worth waiting around.

IC TIP: Sell at 389p
Tip style
Sell
Risk rating
High
Timescale
Medium Term
Bull points

Turnaround plans

Debt free

Bear points

Management envisages years of work needed

Weak cash generation

Falling margins

Brexit risk

In 2018, Castings extended the lifespan of CNC's recently acquired plant and machinery items from 10 to 15 years, which had the welcome effect of adding £0.5m to first-half profit through a corresponding reduction in the depreciation charge. Investment in the machining operation was reduced from £2.7m to £1.3m in the half although the foundry business still needed to £2.3m in first-half productivity initiatives. It is pinning its hopes on automation as the main cure to its productivity problems. So Castings is planning on making existing machinery work for 50 per cent longer, while bringing new technology into play. The company partly blamed inefficiency-led profit decline in the foundry shop on “the introduction of new production processes”.

Castings is also being disrupted by changes to the market and the expectations of customers, who now want to buy a finished or semi-finished parts. We’re far from confident that Castings is operationally adept enough to keep up with the pace of change while addressing its existing struggles. Brexit uncertainty threatens to undermine its recovery, too. Ninety-seven per cent of its revenues were generated across the UK, Sweden, the Netherlands and the rest of Europe in its last full year.

Over the last two years, problems have been reflected in a sharp decline in operating margin (from 14.7 per cent in 2016 to 8.9 per cent last year), and return on year-end capital employed (15.2 per cent to 9.0 per cent). Meanwhile, rising levels of stock and debtors (amounts owed to Castings) to sales since 2016 points to a deteriorating balance sheet (see graph). Working capital increases as well as capital spending on productivity improvements been reflected in a fall in net cash from £40m at the end of March 2016 to £20m at the end of September 2018, although a good chunk of this is explained by the payment of a £13.1m special dividend. 

CASTINGS (CGS)   
ORD PRICE:383.0pMARKET VALUE:£167m
TOUCH:378-383p12-MONTH HIGH:460pLOW: 362p
FORWARD DIVIDEND YIELD:4.2%FORWARD PE RATIO:11
NET ASSET VALUE:294pNET CASH£20m
Year toTurnoverPre-taxEarningsDividend
31 Mar(£m)profit (£m)*per share (p)*per share (p)
Year to 31 MarTurnover (£m)Pre-tax profit (£m)*Earnings per share (p)*Dividend per share (p)
201613219.737.113.7
201711915.929.814.0
201813312.022.214.5
2019*13716.530.915.4
2020*14018.033.915.9
% change+2+9+10-
Normal market size:750   
Beta:0.36   
*Arden Partners forecasts, adjusted profit and EPS figures