Join our community of smart investors

What Black Forest mochas and Black Friday sales have in common

Sales aren't always what they seem
November 24, 2022
  • Price discrimination tactics let firms ‘smoke out’ different customer groups 
  • Bargain hunters: beware

The Undercover Economist opens with a chapter on coffee shops. I am always reminded of it when elaborate festive drinks start appearing on coffee shop menus: Tim Harford argues that by charging wildly different prices for drinks that cost a similar amount to make, coffee shops can “smoke out” customers who are insensitive to price. After all, if the person in front of you in the queue is ordering a large Black Forest mocha with whipped cream and extra syrup, they are probably not on the lookout for a bargain. 

This kind of information is hugely valuable for retailers. If sellers can work out which groups are price sensitive, they can offer them a lower price. This isn’t as outlandish as it sounds: we see it frequently with student and senior discounts. If retailers can identify other groups as reliably less price sensitive, they can do the opposite, exploiting their higher willingness to pay by charging steeper prices. This is relatively well tolerated, too: expensive peak time tickets for time-pressed travellers are a textbook example. 

This is subscriber only content
Start your trial to keep reading
PRINT AND DIGITAL trial

Get 12 weeks for £12
  • Essential access to the website and app
  • Magazine delivered every week
  • Investment ideas, tools and analysis
Have an account? Sign in