Join our community of smart investors

You're suspended!

FEATURE: What can investors do if they hold shares in a company that's been suspended from Aim or the LSE?
June 9, 2011

Since the launch of the Alternative Investment Market (Aim) in 1995, more than 3,000 companies from across the globe have chosen to join the London Stock Exchange's (LSE) international market for smaller companies. The total number of companies on Aim grew from 10 on 19 June 1995 to 1,694 at its peak in 2007. Yet Aim's success has also been its undoing. In 1999 and 2000 Aim was awash with investment companies, commonly known as 'shells' which had nothing more than a germ of an idea for a particular investment arena. Many of these shells were dragging their heels and failing to make suitable investments and this began to tarnish Aim's reputation.

So new rules were introduced in 2005 to combat the problem of inactive shell companies. An investment company must now raise a minimum of £3m in cash on or immediately before admission; it must make an acquisition within 12 months of its admission to Aim; it must exceed 50 per cent in each of the relevant class tests and, finally, it must file its reports on time.

A company's shares are automatically suspended if it is unable to make an investment within the one-year time frame and then, if after a further six months it still has not made any investments, its admission is cancelled. Likewise, a company that is unable to file its results on time also has its shares suspended.

Partly as a result of these rules the number of companies on Aim has dropped. At the end of March 2011 there were 1,174 companies with a total market value of £82bn – 30 per cent fewer than at its peak. And the total number of international and UK companies admitted to Aim each year has been dwindling; 519 companies joined in 2005, compared with just 102 in 2010.

Suspensions also happen as a result of reverse takeovers – although these are only temporary. Two years ago more than 40 companies appeared on the suspension list. Stripping out the companies that have been temporarily suspended while takeovers go through, there were just 24 companies on the list as at 20 April 2011 and this includes both Aim companies and those on the main market (see table below).

If you own shares in a company that has been suspended now is the time to take action. The more information you keep, the easier it will be for you down the line. First of all, find out if there is a potential exit route. Advanced UK Trust and Bede, for example, are returning cash to shareholders. Hephaestus has applied to join Sharemark, a private market. Prime Focus filed its interim accounts and has resumed trading, while Pan Pacific Aggregates is in advanced discussions regarding a potential reverse takeover and, if all goes well, trading will then resume.

If there is no exit route, the shares will be de-listed. As soon as this happens you must contact your local tax office and explain the situation, passing on as much information as you can. HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) considers Aim companies to be unquoted and does not therefore include them in its list of companies deemed to be of negligible value. However, you can still claim losses made on investments in Aim companies.

If you own shares in a company that went into receivership, no longer has a quote on the stock market and does not appear in the list of companies officially declared to be of negligible value, you may still be able to offset the loss against any capital gains you have made. It could just be that, as HMRC says on its website, "a negligible value claim has not been previously considered". It is important to contact your local tax inspector and explain the situation in full. Your claim will then be transferred to the Shares and Assets Valuation Office if appropriate. If approved, the company's name will then be added to the list. HMRC produces several booklets on the subject of capital gains tax (CGT) and an introduction to the share valuation division (SVD1) and these may be obtained from your local tax office or on its website: www.hmrc.gov.uk.

The negligible value list

In the past it was difficult for investors to track down information on companies declared to be of negligible value by HMRC. We lobbied HMRC to make the list more accessible and, thanks to our efforts, you can now find the complete list of shares of negligible value at www.hmrc.gov.uk. It contains the name of the company, the type of security, and the tax year or specific date at which the shares were accepted as being of negligible value.

HMRC has passed on some helpful comments regarding companies whose shares are deemed to be of negligible value:

■ It is not the company as such that is agreed to be worthless, but specific classes of share or other security issued by the company in question. In principle, you might have one class of share or security in company X that had become worthless when another class of share or security in company X still had value.

General guidance on negligible value claims can be found here.

■ People can make a claim that the asset has become worthless and they are then treated as if they had disposed of the asset and reacquired it at the negligible value. A "negligible value claim" enables the claimant to crystallise a loss on their "worthless" asset at the time of the deemed disposal. The time of the deemed disposal is the time at which the claim is made, but the taxpayer may be able to backdate the time for a couple of tax years depending on the circumstances.

■ There is no set time frame for agreeing that shares (or any other asset) are of negligible value because it depends on someone to choose to make a "negligible value claim". There is no particular "best time" for the taxpayer to make a negligible value claim. As long as a person continues to own the asset and the conditions for a claim are met, they can make a claim. The time at which a loss arises depends on the time when a claim is made and whether it is backdated or not. Individual investors will take into account their personal circumstances when deciding whether and at what time to claim.

Suspended companies

CompanySuspended on ReasonContactTelLatest information
Advanced UK Trust15/03/2010Voluntary liquidation. Laura Waters & Richard Setchin appointed liquidatorsCavendish Administration020 7490 4355Third interim cash distribution paid 28/2/11.
Ardana27/06/2008Unable to complete a sale or merger within a timeframeErnst & Young0121 535 2656No updates available.
Bede10/09/2008Administrator appointedBDO Stoy Hayward0113 244 3839Awaiting return to shareholders.
Bolton 02/01/2008Continues to look at properties in emerging markets_020 7278 4343No material events or transactions have taken place.
Boustead07/02/2005Audit qualification020 7491 7674Shares hope to be restored following discussions with UKLA.
Cashbox09/11/2010YourCash believes the company was in breach of certain provisions of the loan noteDeloitte01256 441000Business placed into administration.
CDU09/06/2011Was unable to file its report and accounts on timeSlimma/Stephen Thwaite01538 399141Administrative receivers appointed.
Erinaceous14/04/2008Refinancing failedJames Tucker and Myles Halley0207457 2020No updates available.
Forth Ports27/05/2011Takeover by Otter PortsCharles Hammond0131 555 8700Delisted 3/6/11.
Gaskell18/12/2006Pending clarification of its financial situationGerry Wheeler01254 770222No updates available.
Hawtin29/03/2011Pending clarification of its financial situation. Unable to meet guarantee liabilityNicola Crickmore01633 682130PwC appointed administrators 4/4/11.
Healthcare Enterprise21/12/2010Unable to find a suitable investment and failed to produce accounts on timeJohn Gunn020 7680 3649Pending clarification on its financial situation.
Healthcare Locums25/01/2011Accounting irregularitiesPeter Sullivan020 7451 1451Audit of financial results have commenced. Three executive directors have been appointed. Next update end-June.
Hephaestus17/03/2011Reverse takeover – costs involved in reapplying for admission to Aim too muchChris Hemingway07802 305579Applying for the company's shares to be dealt on Sharemark. Further restructuring measures under way, including a share buy-back.
Jarvis25/03/2010Placed into administration after insufficient support for company to continue tradingSteven Norris01904 712667In administration.
Lambert Howarth15/10/2009Fund-raising cancelled along with customer ordersBDO Stoy Hayward0113 244 3839Administrators appointed.
Leed Petroleum30/03/2011Financial position become uncertainStephen Mischler020 3206 7203Sold oil & gas assets for $16m to pay off debt.
Litho Supplies21/12/2009Clarification of its financial situationMichael Hammond01332 873921Administrators appointed.
OEM03/03/2008Unable to publish financial information due to litigation against the estate of former CEO & othersMichael Kiely020 7216 4636In creditors voluntary liquidation and liquidators have been appointed.
Pan Pacific Aggregates17/01/2011In discussions regarding a potential transaction (reverse takeover)William Voaden0207398 7702Discussions are at an advanced stage. Meeting held on 7/6/11. Company Voluntary Arrangement was approved.
PeerTV02/02/2011Technical problems hit costs and salesEatamar Drory00 972 974 07315Reached agreement in principle with DigiTek.
Prime Focus30/09/2010Unable to release its interim accounts on timeNamit Malhotra020 7565 1000Late interim results were filed on 11/4/11. Resumed trading on Aim.
Romag31/01/2011Disclosure of a payment from John Kennair to the companyNeil Matthews0191 202 5408Refinancing unsuccessful and administrators have been appointed. Potential cancellation date was 5/5/11. No return to shareholders.
Shieldtech18/10/2010Sustained fall in demand for body armourRSM Tenon Recovery0118 953 0350Administrators have been appointed