Join our community of smart investors

Direct Line facing motor cover uncertainty

RESULTS: Lower weather-related claims have boosted profits at insurer Direct Line - but an uncertain outlook in the cut-throat motor market could yet hit the shares
August 2, 2014

Lower weather-related losses at the home and commercial operations largely explain this solid first-half performance from insurer Direct Line (DLG). Indeed, its combined ratio (of claims to premiums) improved from last year's loss-making 101 per cent to a profitable 94.6 per cent.

IC TIP: Sell at 233p

That weather-related boost, for example, helped the home unit's combined ratio to improve to an impressively profitable 86.3 per cent from a loss-making 103.4 per cent. But plenty of challenges remain in the cut-throat motor market, where Direct Line generates 55 per cent of operating profit. The group's second-quarter motor premium rates fell 3 per cent year on year - which, admittedly, isn't bad in a market where, on average, rates are falling by over 8 per cent. Meanwhile recent legislative moves, such as banning legal referral fees, could yet cut claims. But motor pricing pressures look set to persist, and a Competition Commission probe into this sector - due to report in the autumn - adds to the uncertainty.

The investment book is 98 per cent focused on safe-looking cash and bonds and generated a 2.3 per cent return - reasonable enough in today's low yield world.

Broker Numis Securities expects full-year pre-tax profit of £285.6m, giving EPS of 23.3p (from £249.1m and 21.3p in 2012) and net tangible assets (NTA) of 160.5p.

DIRECT LINE (DLG)

ORD PRICE:233pMARKET VALUE:£3.5bn
TOUCH:233-234p12-MONTH HIGH:238pLOW: 175p
DIVIDEND YIELD:5.2%PE RATIO:14
NET ASSET VALUE: 186pCOMBINED RATIO:94.6%

Half-year to 30 JunNet premiums (£bn)Pre-tax profit (£m)Investment return (£m)Dividend per share (p)
20121.87107176nil†
20131.772091054.20
% change-5+95-40-

Ex-div: 14 Aug

Payment: 26 Sep

†Prior to flotation